The importance of weak forces
- London dispersion forces are weak but additive and affect the boiling points of alkenes
London dispersion forces - instantaneous dipole-induced dipole attractions - are extremely short ranged, non-directional, transitory and weak, ranging from 0.1-5 kJ mol-1. So why study them?
The answer to this question is that most molecules, including those involved in hydrogen bonding, are attracted to each other by these weak forces, and they can have a significant effect on the physical properties of the molecule. In an effort to get students to appreciate this, we ask them to propose why, at 1.0 atmos and room temperature, non-polar Br2 is a liquid with a boiling point of 58.8 oC, while straight chain decane (C10H22) is a fluid that boils at 174 oC.
Polarisability definedWe start by defining polarisability as a measure of the ease by which the electronic environment of an atom or molecule can be distorted to produce an electronic dipole, which is a function of capacitance and has the SI unit of C m2 V-1. We explain that as the polarisability increases, so do inter-atomic and inter-molecular forces of attraction and boiling points.1
We can calculate the contributing polarisability value of each CH3 and CH2 unit in a normal alkane molecule by the following reasoning: the polarisability of ethane is 4.47 C m2 V-1 and by assigning half of the value to each CH3 unit, we obtain a value of 2.24 C m2 V-1 per CH3. By using the polarisability value of 6.29 C m2 V-1 for propane,2 and subtracting 4.47 C m2 V-1 for the two CH3 units, we can estimate the contribution of a CH2 unit to be 1.81 C m2 V-1.
Table 1 Estimated and literature polarisability, boiling point and standard enthalpy of vaporisation at the boiling point of seven straight chain alkanes.
By studying Table 1 and Fig 1, students can see the correlation between an increase in the number of CH2 units, polarisability and boiling point. Students should also recognise that the cumulative effect of 'weak' London dispersion forces of attraction associated with each CH3 and CH2 unit can become large enough to cause some alkanes to boil at temperatures in excess of 100 oC.
Fig 1. The relationship between boiling points and the number of carbon atoms from methane to decane
Moreover, as the distance between non-polar alkanes decreases and the polarisability increases, the standard enthalpies of vaporisation also increase, according to: 3,4
H ovap ~ E London forces ~ ?2/r6 (i)
where is the polarisability and r is the distance between two nuclei that are in separate molecules.
As the effectiveness of London dispersion forces of attraction increases, so do Hovap and boiling points. The relationship between boiling point and enthalpy at one atmosphere pressure and with one mole of liquid may be mathematically expressed as:
T b= Hovap/Sovap
The effect of London dispersion forces of attraction depends on the portions of separate molecules that are in close contact with each other: the greater the surface area of close proximity, the stronger are the net forces of attraction and the higher are both the boiling point and standard enthalpy of vaporisation.5-7 As the number of methylene groups (CH2) increases for a straight chain alkane, so the surface area for close contact also increases, and '. since there is no limit to the size of molecules, these intermolecular forces of attraction can become quite large'.3
For a branch alkane, the main chain is shorter than its straight chain geometric isomer, and has less surface area of close contact. Thus the branched chain alkane has less efficient London dispersion forces of attraction. 8 Computer modelling demonstrates that the molecular surfaces of branched hydrocarbons have fissures and corners and the atoms involved with side chains are within the surface fractures and bends.7,8 Atoms in these locations do not increase the overall effectiveness of London dispersion forces of attraction. Table 2 reveals the differences in boiling points between C5H12 and C8H18 straight chain and branched molecules.
Table 2 Boiling point and standard enthalpy for straight chain and branched alkanes.
Thus the additive effect of the London dispersion forces of attraction associated with each CH3 and CH2 unit in different structures reflects the significance of these weak forces when studying or applying chemistry.
Dr Manus Monroe teaches chemistry in the department of chemistry, Sonoma State University, Rohnert Park, CA 94928, US.
My thanks to the referees for their constructive comments on this article.
1. W. Kauzmann, Quantum chemistry, an introduction, p515. New York: Academic Press,1957.
2. Handbook of chemistry and physics, 87th edn, David R. Lide (eds). New York: CRC, LLC, 2006-07.
3. R. E. Dickerson, H. B. Gray, M. Y. Darensbourgh and J. Donald, Chemical principles, p512, 4th edn. Menlo Park: Benjamin/Cummings Publishing, 1984.
4. G. M. Barrow, Physical chemistry, p516, 3rd edn. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1967.
5. P. Y. Bruice, Organic chemistry, p74, 5th edn. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2007.
6. H. J. Wiener, J. Am. Chem. Soc ., 1947, 69, 17.
7. R. C. Mebane et al, J. Chem. Educ ., 1999, 76, 688.
8. K. B. Lipkoeitz, J. Chem. Educ., 1989, 66, 275.