Feature Articles are invited by the ChemComm Editorial Board. You are asked to assess the paper, paying particular attention to the points outlined below. Please bear in mind that the readership of ChemComm is very wide ranging and the purpose of a Feature Article is to bring them up-to-date with research in a particular field. It is therefore essential that the Feature Article is clearly written, up-to-date, authoritative, and easily comprehensible to the non-specialist.

Feature articles should be written from a personal point of view, and ideally should be the first review of a new significant area, bringing together the results of various primary publications. A comprehensive review of the literature is not required, but due credit should be given to other workers in the field.

1. How would you rate this paper? *
   
   Excellent
   Good
   Routine
   Poor/Unacceptable

   
   

2. Does the article provide explanation and introduction at a level intelligible to the non-specialist? *
   
   Yes
   No
   

   
   

3. Is the subject of the article of sufficient interest to justify the space it will occupy? *
   
   Yes
   No
   

   
   

4. Does the article identify areas where further developments are needed? *
   
   Yes
   No
   

   
   

5. Are the references up-to-date and accessible, and have all key references been cited? *
   
   Yes
   No
   
   Please give details in your comments of any citations that have been omitted.

   
   

6. What is your recommendation? *
   
   Accept - unchanged
   Accept - with minor revisions
   Accept - after major revisions
   Reject
   
   Your recommendation cannot be used unless justification is provided. Please support your recommendation in your comments.

   
   

Type/paste your comments here: *

OR Upload a document file - MS Word (.doc), plain text (.txt) or Acrobat (.pdf) files only:

OPTIONAL Comments for Editorial Office only: