Rivalry in science


Prize fight
Morton Meyers
Palgrave Macmillan
2012 | 272pp | £16.99 (HB)
ISBN 9780230338906
Reviewed by Ian Le Guillou

While winners are written into the history books and their names synonymous with success, those in second place are quickly forgotten. This is as true in science as it is in sport. But assigning credit for scientific advances can be a tricky business, whether it is the order of authors on a paper or awarding a Nobel prize.

Meyers starts with several accounts of obvious misbehaviour by scientists aiming for glory, including unrightfully claiming credit or even falsifying data. While some of these cases are rather shocking, they are fairly straightforward and only serve to show the less savoury side of the scientific world.

It is really in the second part that the book gets up to speed. Meyers investigates two high profile cases in medical science, looking at them in depth and showing just how complicated assigning due credit can be.

The first story concerns the discovery of streptomycin by microbiologist Selman Waksman and graduate student Albert Schatz. The second examines the rivalry between magnetic resonance imaging pioneers Raymond Damadian and Paul Lauterbur. In both examples, one party received the Nobel prize while the other was sidelined. Although each case has its own reasons for controversy, there is a running theme of the determined and desperate mindset of a scientist who feels that he is being written out of history.

While the book as a whole is heavily focused on medical research, its stories ring true across all fields. Meyers structures the stories so that the reader will change their opinion throughout the book, showing just how difficult it is to arbitrate on cases like these. As he concludes, awareness of these issues could help to prevent them happening again in the future, but perhaps that’s just wishful thinking.

Purchase Prize fight from Amazon.co.uk.


Related Content

Live blog: Single molecule spectroscopy wins chemistry Nobel prize

8 October 2014 News and Analysis

news image

Keep up with the latest news and gossip on the chemistry Nobel prize

Nobel double whammy for chemistry

1 November 2013 Editorial

news image

Is 'they don't do "real" chemistry' the worst argument ever?

Most Read

Higher levels of some metals in e-cigarette smoke

8 September 2014 Research

news image

Scientists call for regulators to help clear smoke and mirrors surrounding vaping safety

Isotope effect produces new type of chemical bond

22 October 2014 Research

news image

Evidence emerges for vibrational bond first proposed 30 years ago

Most Commented

Indian U-turn on diabetes drug ban

16 August 2013 News and Analysis

news image

Suspension of cheap and popular medicine reversed but will now come with new safety warnings

DNA waves don't wash

10 July 2013 The Crucible

news image

Philip Ball asks why a spectacular claim seems to have been overlooked. Sometimes science doesn’t work the way it’s suppo...