Entropy and the second law: interpretation and misss-interpretationsss


Arieh Ben-Naim
World Scientific 
2012 | 296pp | £12
ISBN 9789814374897
Reviewed by Richard Henchman
 
In the long-running debate about the best way to teach and understand entropy in thermodynamics, Arieh Ben-Naim forcefully advocates the probabilistic interpretation of thermodynamic entropy in terms of (Claude) Shannon’s measure of information (SMI). The SMI is an equation, which is not immediately obvious, that sums the logarithm of each microstate’s probability, weighted by its probability, over all of a system’s microstates.
 
In guiding readers ‘in choosing their own interpretation of entropy’, Ben-Naim confronts a number of so-called ‘misss-interpretationsss’ [sic]. These include the qualitative descriptors of disorder, chaos, freedom, mixing, spreading and even information, all of which frequently lead to ambiguity and confusion. For example, mixing is equivalent to expansion, or a uniform distribution has higher entropy than a non-uniform one. He maintains the superiority of SMI over the equivalent equations proposed decades earlier by Ludwig Boltzmann and Josiah Gibbs because of SMI’s greater generality to any distribution of any kind of information, a somewhat tenuous name-change. He saves his strongest criticism for Frank Lambert, the main advocate of explaining entropy change as the dispersal of energy. This is the approach inspired by Rudolf Clausius’ equality, which equates entropy change to heat flow divided by temperature. In a biblical allusion, Lambert is diplomatically compared to a lion’s carcass bringing forth the honey of this book. 
 
Of all these approaches, is there a best way to understand entropy, let alone teach it? Macroscopic or microscopic? Qualitative or quantitative? Familiar or abstract? A difference between states or an absolute state? The state of a person who already understands entropy may be fairly well defined but there are many more paths of learning leading to it. Even though the SMI belongs to the core theory for predicting entropy, does that make it the best way to learn it? Building on a long series of books, Ben-Naim does a thorough job in making the SMI a familiar and intuitive quantity. He presents his case in a very readable examination of entropy’s multifaceted nature, and contends that even Humpty-Dumpty might one day be put back together again.
 
Purchase Entropy and the second law from Amazon.co.uk

Related Content

Maxwell’s demon gets scribbling

30 July 2013 Research

news image

Demon can transfer energy from cold to hot reservoir if it simultaneously generates information, researchers claim

The last retort

6 January 2010 Premium contentLast Retort

news image

Dramatised by Alan Lightman, the second law of thermodynamics incorporates the theory of entropy

Most Read

Isotope effect produces new type of chemical bond

22 October 2014 Research

news image

Evidence emerges for vibrational bond first proposed 30 years ago

Not all science is created equal

16 October 2014 Comments

news image

John Ioannidis explains why researchers should be curious about the differences between disciplines

Most Commented

UCLA spent $4.5 million on legal costs in Sangji case

20 October 2014 News and Analysis

news image

University defends spending in case brought against chemistry professor, highlighting $20 million investment in lab safety

Not all science is created equal

16 October 2014 Comments

news image

John Ioannidis explains why researchers should be curious about the differences between disciplines