Appeal reverses ECHA call for animal tests


An appeal has overturned the European Chemicals Agency’s (ECHA) request for additional animal toxicity testing on the automotive air-conditioning refrigerant 2,3,3,3-tetrafluoropropene (HFO-1234yf).

The requested test would oppose the ECHA’s responsibility under the Reach (registration, evaluation, authorisation and restriction of chemicals) regulation to ensure that animal tests are only undertaken as a last resort, and that any testing involves the minimum number of animals, the ECHA’s board of appeal has ruled.

In 2010, the ECHA requested that Honeywell Belgium, which submitted the Reach dossier on the compound, complete an extended study of its toxicity in rabbits. Honeywell argued that such a test could not reliably provide the information the ECHA required, and that existing data were sufficient to assess the compound’s toxicity.

The case will now be referred back to the ECHA for further action. In a statement Honeywell said that it is ‘looking forward to reviewing existing data and testing with the ECHA’.

HFO-1234yf is produced by a joint venture between Honeywell and DuPont as a greener alternative to other fluorinated refrigerants, which have much higher global warming potential.


Related Content

EU chemicals regulator scolded over animal testing

24 December 2014 Business

news image

Ombudsman says ECHA isn’t doing enough to require alternative, non-animal methods

Data sharing helps firms reduce Reach animal testing

6 June 2014 Business

news image

Alternative in vitro methods slowly gaining traction for some tests

Most Read

Agatha Christie, the queen of crime chemistry

28 August 2015 Feature

news image

Kathryn Harkup looks at how Agatha Christie used her chemical training in her detective novels

Simple chemistry saving thousands of gold miners from mercury poisoning

25 August 2015 News and Analysis

news image

Basic apparatus is cutting mercury pollution and helping Indonesian miners go for gold

Most Commented

A risky business

28 August 2015 In the Pipeline

news image

Graduate research is likely the most risky time of a chemist’s career, says Derek Lowe

Exploiting the data mine

13 August 2015 Feature

news image

Chemists must embrace open data to allow us to collectively get the best out of the masses of new knowledge we unearth, repor...