Thermoelectric cost analysis


Scientists from the US have derived a metric to analyse the cost of power generation using thermoelectric technology. The metric shows that thermoelectric devices have greater potential in large-scale power generation than previously thought.

Thermoelectric generators convert heat into electricity by a physical phenomenon called the Seebeck effect. They are compact, robust, and have no moving parts. This means they are useful for low-maintenance applications, such as in spacecrafts. However, their device efficiencies – the power produced for a certain heat flow – are low, so they are not used for large-scale power generation.

Thermoelectric research has typically focussed on the dimensionless figure-of-merit ZT, a metric that relates directly to device efficiency. Shannon Yee from the University of California Berkeley, part of the team that performed the analysis, explains that for power generation to be commercially viable, what really matters is a technology’s capital cost per watt and not just its device efficiency: ‘we found that the design that minimises a system’s cost per watt value is generally very different to the design that maximises efficiency.’

The team developed a comprehensive metric that takes into account the device architecture, manufacturing costs and materials costs, including the cost of the components, called heat exchangers, that harvest heat on the hot side and reject it on the cold side. They found that for many realistic designs it is actually the device components rather than the thermoelectric material that dominate the overall system cost.

Ali Shakouri, an expert in thermoelectric technology at the University of Purdue, US, was enthused by the work pointing out that we do not have to wait for major breakthroughs in thermoelectric materials to realise the benefits of thermoelectric energy conversion systems. Another leading figure in thermoelectric research, Gang Chen from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, in the US, agrees: ‘the field has been focusing on ZT. This paper directs attention to cost per watt, which is what really matters in real world applications.’

The analysis identifies several new research directions. One area in particular, says Yee, is the need to improve the plates that sandwich the thermoelectric material. ‘If the costs of certain critical system components could be reduced, even some existing thermoelectric materials could become cost competitive in a design that minimises the cost per watt value.’


Related Content

Power up with body heat

4 April 2014 Research

news image

Repeated bending is not a problem for new wearable thermoelectric generator

Turning heat into electricity with polymers

3 May 2011 News Archive

news image

Controlling the oxidation state of a conducting polymer could provide a cheap way to turn heat into electricity

Most Read

Quintuple bond activates small stable molecules

19 September 2014 Research

news image

Exotic complexes suggest route to synthetic feedstock

Computer simulations point to formamide as prebiotic intermediate in ‘Miller’ mixtures

16 September 2014 News and Analysis

news image

Electric field may have provided more than just energy for primordial chemistry

Most Commented

US genomics lead being lost to China

17 September 2014 News and Analysis

news image

NIH senior leaders are sounding the alarm bells, saying the US's pre-eminence in genomics research is under threat

The trouble with boycotts

29 August 2014 Critical Point

news image

Cutting academic ties with a censured state can do more harm than good, says Mark Peplow