Commons’ report echoes past messages on women in science


The UK is continuing to make slow progress in increasing the number of women in science and keeping them there © Shutterstock

Less talk, more action is the message from the House of Commons select committee on science and technology following another investigation into why there are still so few women at the top levels of science and engineering, despite ‘clear imperatives and multiple initiatives’.

The committee admitted that its inquiry did not uncover any new issues on the topic of gender diversity in science, technology, engineering and maths (Stem) subjects, but that the situation was still changing very slowly. ‘The problems and solutions have long been identified,’ the report states, ‘yet not enough is being done to actively improve the situation.’

Andrew Miller MP, chair of the committee, says: ‘It is astonishing that women still remain under-represented at professorial levels in academia across every scientific discipline. It’s time for universities to pull their socks up.’

Short-term contracts are hugely off-putting for many women scientists, and while some universities are doing a great job at improving working conditions, Miller says, others are not. ‘More standardisation is required across the whole higher education sector and that is why we have called for government, universities and research councils to review the academic careers structure.’

The committee criticised the government for focusing mainly on recruiting girls to study Stem subjects rather than on supporting women to stay in science. ‘Such efforts are wasted if women scientists are then disproportionately and systematically disadvantaged compared to men,’ Miller says.

The Royal Society of Chemistry’s president, Lesley Yellowlees, welcomed the report and is particularly pleased that it acknowledged the need for data to track where women work after they graduate from science courses, which are seriously lacking at the moment. ‘We need the right information about women scientists leaving academia to get a clear understanding of the situation and to use it as a solid base for shaping future policy.’

Athene Donald, the University of Cambridge’s gender equality champion and a professor of experimental physics, does not share Miller’s astonishment at the absence of women at professorial level as this is ‘something she sees every day’. But, she says, many of the problems identified – such as the question of the whole career structure in academic science – need a great deal more collective will to solve than can be provided by individual higher education institutions (HEIs). ‘Moving away from short-term postdoc contracts would need a radical shift in the way funders fund research. It would require a major rethink and collective action involving far more than simply the research councils.’

Donald points out that most of the committee’s recommendations were directed at HEIs and yet that is probably where most of the action is already happening, even if it is piecemeal. Funders could do much more to supplement whatever HEIs do, including ensuring their own practices are without fault, she says. This includes directing new money to help women returning to careers, ensuring all teachers receive unconscious bias training and providing adequate face-to-face careers advice.


Related Content

Chemistry World podcast - April 2014

4 April 2014 Podcast | Monthly

news image

Why are researchers boycotting a conference? How can Raman spectroscopy reveal the true colours of paintings? And how can shr...

Stemming the tide

21 August 2013 Feature

news image

Women are leaving chemistry in greater numbers than men. Laura Howes looks at how to mend the leaky pipeline

Most Read

Coated nanoparticles show Alzheimer's promise

12 September 2014 News and Analysis

news image

Gold nanoparticles functionalised with amino acid polymer inhibit the growth of amyloid fibres associated with neurodegenerat...

First flexible graphene display paves the way for folding electronics

11 September 2014 News and Analysis

news image

Team behind the bendy e-reader display hope to have a full colour graphene-based smartphone style screen within a year

Most Commented

Does life play dice?

3 September 2014 The Crucible

news image

Philip Ball wonders whether life evolved to exploit quantum phenomena, or if it’s just in our nature

The trouble with boycotts

29 August 2014 Critical Point

news image

Cutting academic ties with a censured state can do more harm than good, says Mark Peplow