$1.2bn J&J deceptive marketing fine overturned


The Arkansas Supreme Court has overturned a lower court’s fine of $1.2 billion (£725 million), imposed on Johnson & Johnson’s subsidiary Janssen in April 2012 over its marketing of antipsychotic drug Risperdal (risperidone).

The state of Arkansas’s case against Janssen revolves around its handling of a request by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to inform doctors of possible side effects of the whole class of atypical antipsychotics, to which risperidone belongs. Briefly, the case contends that Janssen misled doctors about the safety of risperidone relative to other drugs, causing them to prescribe it favourably. Since many of these prescriptions were paid for by the US Medicaid scheme for helping poor patients afford drugs, Arkansas claims the company defrauded the state.

In part, the fine was overturned because the Supreme Court decided that law that the State was accusing Janssen of contravening applies to healthcare institutions, not pharmaceutical companies. Janssen is awaiting a ruling in South Carolina over similar allegations, and a similar case in Louisiana was overturned in January. None of these cases are related to the J&J’s $2.2 billion fine from a federal case brought by the US Department of Justice over mismarketing of Risperdal.


Related Content

Weathering the storm

6 January 2014 Business

news image

Pharmaceutical industry roundup 2013

Another drug suspension overturned in India

6 September 2013 News and Analysis

news image

Safety concerns put sales of antidepressant Deanxit on ice until firms petitioned a high court

Most Read

No-frills coats set a trend for designer viruses

26 August 2014 Research

news image

An artificial protein that self-assembles around and protects DNA could be ideal for gene therapy, nanomachines and synthetic...

History of King Richard III written in his teeth

18 August 2014 Research

news image

Chemical analysis of isotope signatures in monarch's remains provide insight into his life

Most Commented

The energy to fight injustice

23 July 2014 Comments

news image

Giving the world carbon-free energy means putting nuclear energy back on the agenda, says James Hansen

Next Mars rover will make oxygen from CO2

4 August 2014 News and Analysis

news image

Mars 2020 will set Nasa’s space exploration on a self-sufficiency course