Separation by levitation


A team in the US has shown that enantiopure and racemic crystals can be separated by magnetic levitation.

The isolation of pure enantiomers is of particular importance in the pharmaceutical industry, where one enantiomer is typically responsible for the therapeutic effects of a drug, while the other may be inactive or even toxic. One alternative to the often used solution-based separation techniques such as high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) is to purify the desired enantiomer from a mixture of crystals of enantiomerically pure and racemic compound.

Separation of a mixture of S-ibuprofen (red arrow) and RS-ibuprofen (yellow arrow) using MagLev

As enantiopure and racemic crystals generally have different densities due to distinct packing arrangements of the molecules, they can be levitated in a paramagnetic solution to different heights by the balance of magnetic and gravitational forces and then separated.

Using four sequential magnetic levitation (MagLev) separations, a team led by Allan Myerson at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology purified a 1:1 mixture of S- and RS-ibuprofen to 99.2% ee.

‘Chiral resolution, especially during drug discovery, requires tedious method development by an experienced scientist to achieve efficient separation,’ says Syed Rizvi, a chiral separations and pharmaceutical analysis expert at Nova Southeastern University in the US. ‘The MagLev technique however is quite simple, inexpensive and has great potential to become a routine method for chiral separation.’

Despite its simplicity, the use of MagLev on a large scale presents a number of challenges. ‘As it requires that the racemic crystal forms reliably, does not stick to enantiomerically pure crystals, and has a different density, it is more likely to be used in an analytical laboratory setting engaged in preclinical studies of a compound,’ says Myerson. The need for an equilibration time for the drug crystals to settle as well as the choice of paramagnetic medium also need to be considered.

The team are currently working to apply MagLev to the purification of other chiral compounds, and hope to extend their technique to the separation of cocrystals.

References

This paper is free to access until 30 July 2014. Download it here:

X Yang et al, Chem. Commun., 2014, DOI: 10.1039/c4cc02604g


Related Content

Nanoparticle composites make colourful magnetic crystals

20 March 2014 Research

news image

Gel crystallisation loads gold and iron into normally colourless calcite to give it new properties

Beyond graphene

3 January 2014 Feature

news image

Other materials can be made into ultra-thin nanosheets. Jon Evans finds out whether they can generate the same buzz

Most Read

Antimicrobial resistance will kill 300 million by 2050 without action

16 December 2014 News and Analysis

news image

UK report says resistance will cost global economy $100 trillion

Cutting edge chemistry in 2014

10 December 2014 Research

news image

We take a look back at the year's most interesting chemical science stories

Most Commented

A bad business

19 December 2014 Critical Point

news image

Targets and assessments can boost productivity at universities – but only if they do not stifle creativity and alienate the...

Chemistry behind the ‘blue man’ unlocked

1 November 2012 Research

news image

Biochemical model suggests that silver ions, not nanoparticles, cause a rare skin complaint