China struggles to speed up drug reviews


In an effort to accelerate slow regulatory drug reviews, the China Food and Drug Administration (CFDA) is attempting to outsource some reviewing processes and introducing fast-track priority reviews for selected generic drugs.

Yin Li, deputy head of the CFDA, told the annual conference of medical information held in Beijing in May that the CFDA is planning to commission third-party organisations to share the overloaded reviewing responsibilities. In parallel, the agency is also revising regulations for drug registration, such that priority reviews can be given to generics with critical clinical value as well as brand new drugs.

pharmacist with drug package

China wants to prioritise new drugs and certain generics over more routine requests © Shutterstock

Until now, priority reviews were only offered to new drugs included in key national drug development schemes. However, the agency’s Center for Drug Evaluation (CDE), which is responsible for reviewing new drugs, released a target list of priority generics in its 2013 annual report. Most of these are copies of blockbusters whose patents are due to expire around 2014.

It is unclear when the CFDA will begin to outsource reviewing work, although the CDE has reputedly been buried under rising numbers of ‘new drug’ applications, most of them generics, for some time. In 2013, the CDE received 7529 new drug applications, including 6409 applications for chemical drugs (as opposed to traditional Chinese medical remedies and biological drugs), which were nearly all generics.

‘The low quality and repeated applications for generics have not improved,’ says the CDE. Even for generics, few applications are submitted for drugs that are not yet available in China. Most applications are simply modifications to dosage and packaging of existing drugs.

To process all these applications, the CDE employs fewer than 200 drug reviewers, far fewer than US Food and Drug Administration’s 4000 and European Medicines Agency’s 3000. As a result, clinical trials for new drugs are often delayed for more than one year, and approval of new drugs even further. To try and clear the backlog, the CDE has been enrolling temporary drug reviewers from pharmaceutical companies. However, this temporary measure cannot provide sufficient experienced drug reviewers.

Theoretically, outsourcing review work is a realistic solution, given China’s strict control on government agencies’ staff numbers, says Zailin Yu, president of Tianjin-based SinoBiotech. However, he cautions that organisations with sufficient authority to bear the responsibility of new drug reviews might be unavailable in China, owing to the highly technical challenges of the job.

In early 2000, to tighten up lax drug review processes, the then SFDA (State Food and Drug Administration) head Zheng Xiaoyu abolished the right of provincial SFDA branches to conduct reviews, concentrating it to SFDA headquarters. Zheng was executed in 2007 on charges of corruption. According to Yu, there are still many potential drug review experts within the CFDA’s provincial branches and the growing contract research community. However, organising them is difficult.

The CFDA has unnecessarily expended huge and equal reviewing effort on thousands of generics applications each year, says Jin Tuo, a professor of pharmacology at Shanghai Jiaotong University. Tuo suggests reducing review requirements on simple generics to concentrate  limited resources on truly new drugs or generics with important clinical values. 


Related Content

Chinese drug watchdog set for major reforms

19 August 2013 News and Analysis

news image

Measures will speed up drug approvals and decentralise controls on generics

China to fast track pioneering drugs

8 May 2008 News Archive

news image

Special registration rules to speed approval and encourage innovation

Most Read

Higher levels of some metals in e-cigarette smoke

8 September 2014 Research

news image

Scientists call for regulators to help clear smoke and mirrors surrounding vaping safety

Isotope effect produces new type of chemical bond

22 October 2014 Research

news image

Evidence emerges for vibrational bond first proposed 30 years ago

Most Commented

Indian U-turn on diabetes drug ban

16 August 2013 News and Analysis

news image

Suspension of cheap and popular medicine reversed but will now come with new safety warnings

DNA waves don't wash

10 July 2013 The Crucible

news image

Philip Ball asks why a spectacular claim seems to have been overlooked. Sometimes science doesn’t work the way it’s suppo...