Miller’s forgotten experiments point to primitive protein genesis


Stanley Miller's experiments are still adding to our understanding of prebiotic Earth © Scripps Institution of Oceanography, UC San Diego

Stanley Miller was catapulted to instant fame in 1953 by his experiments indicating how the first amino acids could have been produced on Earth, thereby surmounting a major step towards the genesis of life. One question that remained open, however, is how these amino acids polymerised into the first proteins. Now, after analysing samples from a forgotten 1958 Miller experiment, a former student believes that, unbeknown to Miller, a possible answer may have lain undiscovered for over 50 years.

In 1953, Miller combined gaseous methane, ammonia, water and hydrogen in a specially designed reaction vessel and left them for a week, subjecting the material to continual sparks to simulate lightning. When analysed, the mixture contained several amino acids. In 1958, trying to explain how amino acids could condense into proteins, he repeated the reaction, this time adding cyanamide, a condensing reagent used to produce pharmaceuticals.

In 1958, no one had formally proposed that cyanamide was present in the early atmosphere. So why did Miller add it? In the early 1950s, he had been based at Columbia University in the US. ‘In that environment there was an intense amount of work by various people on how to synthesise peptides and proteins to make the first artificial protein,’ says Jeffrey Bada, a former doctoral student of Miller's at the University of California, San Diego, ‘and that was actually done in those labs.’ Bada suspects that, during a seminar or ‘over a beer or something’ someone may have suggested that cyanamide could have been present on the early Earth.

Strangely, despite documenting the experiments and retaining samples, Miller never analysed them. In the late 1960s, other researchers proposed that ultraviolet light could have stimulated methane to react with ammonia in the proto-atmosphere, producing cyanamide. Even then, however, Miller's experiments were not repeated because cyanamide only catalyses amino acid condensation effectively in a mildly acidic environment, while conditions on the early Earth were thought to be neutral or alkaline.

Unusual inheritance

In 1999, after Miller suffered a severe stroke, Bada inherited the samples. Together with colleagues at UCSD and the Georgia Institute of Technology in Atlanta, Bada analysed the samples, identifying 12 amino acids and 10 dipeptides.

After confirming that cyanamide polymerises amino acids only in acidic conditions, the researchers were stumped. ‘I'm thinking: “What the hell is going on here?”’ says Bada. After much thought, the researchers realised that the Strecker synthesis that produces amino acids in these experiments proceeds through two intermediates – an amino nitrile and an amino acid amide. When they added these intermediates to the reaction mixture, the reaction worked perfectly in mildly alkaline conditions. This shows, say the researchers, that, while amino acids will only polymerise into peptides under acidic conditions, the intermediates will do so in alkaline environments.

The total yield of dipeptides and their cyclic forms, diketopiperazines, was about 10%, but Bada argues that, even in small amounts, such chemicals could have done the trick. ‘Some of the simple dipeptides and their cyclic forms (diketopiperazines) that we have identified have been shown to be effective catalysts at low concentrations of a variety of reactions,’ he says. ‘These could have therefore helped to facilitate the formation of more complex molecules that lead to the first type of simple nucleic acid-based self-replicating entities, and thus the origin of life.’

‘This resurrection of Stanley Miller's experiment significantly expands the set of environmental conditions that have been found to support peptide synthesis,’ says Irene Chen of the University of California, Santa Barbara in the US. ‘It is possible that the same mechanism that produced peptides in this experiment could be enhanced under different conditions to produce greater yields.’

Related Content

The molecules that make memory

26 September 2014 Premium contentFeature

news image

The chemistry of making – and losing – memories is increasingly well understood, as Rachel Brazil discovers

Chemistry World podcast - August 2014

5 August 2014 Podcast | Monthly

news image

This month, how artificial comets may explain the origins of asymmetry in life. Plus, we speak to Martyn Poliakoff

Most Read

Higher levels of some metals in e-cigarette smoke

8 September 2014 Research

news image

Scientists call for regulators to help clear smoke and mirrors surrounding vaping safety

Isotope effect produces new type of chemical bond

22 October 2014 Research

news image

Evidence emerges for vibrational bond first proposed 30 years ago

Most Commented

Indian U-turn on diabetes drug ban

16 August 2013 News and Analysis

news image

Suspension of cheap and popular medicine reversed but will now come with new safety warnings

DNA waves don't wash

10 July 2013 The Crucible

news image

Philip Ball asks why a spectacular claim seems to have been overlooked. Sometimes science doesn’t work the way it’s suppo...