Hydrogen bond set to be redefined
03 November 2010
The world authority on chemical nomenclature is preparing to scrap the familiar hydrogen bond definition, in light of recent evidence about its true nature. The International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry's (Iupac's) Physical and Biophysical Chemistry Division has now published its proposal for the revised definition, and the chemical community has until the end of March 2011 to respond. Barring significant objections, it will be adopted shortly thereafter.
The familiar definition of the H bond is set to be overhauled
The current classification also concentrates on fluorine, oxygen and nitrogen, which Arunan says research has been shown as too simplistic. 'Most existing definitions insist hydrogen is connected to the most electronegative atoms,' he tells Chemistry World. 'That is far from complete now.' Arunan points out that Richard Nelmes at the University of Edinburgh, UK discovered that solid hydrogen sulfide has a hydrogen bonding structure resembling ice. 'That's what really shocked chemists,' he says.
Arunan's own research, at the Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, has demonstrated that hydrogen sulfide molecules can hydrogen bond with ethylene. He also notes that methane, noble gases like krypton, and unpaired-electron radical species have been seen as hydrogen's bonding partner.
A 14 member group including hydrogen bonding textbook authors like Utah State University's Steve Scheiner and Arunan's Bangalore colleague Gautam Desiraju has been developing the latest classification since 2004. Arunan hopes that their combined contribution will help minimise any controversy. 'Hydrogen bonding is not string theory or gravitons, which no-one has ever seen yet,' he emphasises. 'There are plenty of experimental and theoretical results available.'
Slawomir Grabowski, a hydrogen bonding expert at the University of the Basque Country in Spain underlines that Nobel laureate Linus Pauling originated the best-used current definition in 1960. 'The change of definition is needed,' he tells Chemistry World, 'but because of the broad spectrum of interactions which exist in nature I am slightly sceptical it's possible to propose a definition that satisfies the whole community of chemists.'
Interesting? Spread the word using the 'tools' menu on the left.
Also of interest
21 May 2010
How hydrogen bonds in water-based systems flip from one partner to another have been measured by US researchers
03 September 2008
Hydroxide ions form extra hydrogen bond to speed through water
International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry
Categorising hydrogen bonding and other intermolecular interactions
Comment on this story at the Chemistry World blog
Read other posts and join in the discussion
External links will open in a new browser window